A chilly wind blows through St. Louis this weekend as temperatures
drop back to something more closely approximating the norm for late
April. By sheer coincidence the musical equivalent of a brisk
northern breeze blows through the Touhill Center, as well, as
frequent guest John Stogårds steps up
to the podium of the St. Louis Symphony
Orchestra (SLSO) to conduct concerts dominated by his fellow
Finn Jean Sibelius (1865–1957) and Danish composer Per Nørgård (b. 1932).
[Preview the music with the SLSO's
Spotify playlist.]
It may be a bit of a cliché, but for me the music of Sibelius
conjures up images of pines, snow, and brisk northern winds. You
can hear that in the Sibelius works that open and close the
program which are, respectively, “Rakastava (The Lover)” and the
Symphony No. 7. That same feeling is present in the work
that precedes the Sibelius Seventh, Nørgård’s 2007 composition
“Lysning (Glade)” for strings and percussion, albeit with a more
contemporary harmonic palette.
Sibelius was notoriously self-critical, often revising works and
even destroying those he deemed inferior. His Symphony No. 8, for
example, was never completed and was eventually burned by the
composer. “Rakastava” didn’t suffer that dire fate, but the
original four-movement 1894 version, for unaccompanied male
chorus, was never published. The composer produced a version for
men's chorus and string orchestra in that same year, and for mixed
choir in 1898, but none of them really caught on.
Finally, in 1912, he recycled “Rakastava” into a three-movement
work for strings and percussion (tympani and triangle) and this
time it was a hit. The work “captivated audiences”
and is now “regarded as a minor
masterpiece.” But don’t take my word for it. Listen to the
recording by Sir Colin Davis and the London Symphony Orchestra on
the SLSO’s Spotify playlist and I think you’ll agree. The romantic
yearning of the first movement (“The Lover”) has an unsettled feel
that’s accentuated by the occasional interruptions for the melodic
flow by an agitated motif in the lower strings and tympani. The
brief second movement (“The Path of the Beloved”) is an ethereal
scherzo reminiscent of Mendelssohn. And the sense of melancholy in
the final movement (“Good Night!... Farewell!”) becomes tragic
about halfway through before setting into quiet resignation.
It’s emotionally complex music with just an occasional frisson
of the cold north wind.
.jpeg) |
Per Nørgård Photo courtesy of the SLSO |
Nørgård’s “Glade,” which opens the second half of the evening,
feels a bit bleak, as well, but not consistently. There is,
rather, a mix of light and shade of the sort you might encounter
in a forest clearing. “There is a balance between the number of
darker and lighter sections,” writes the composer,
“as each ‘light’ section presents the same material as the ‘dark’
section before it—but heard from different instrumental colorings
and nuances.” The unresolved feeling of the final moments of the
work makes it a perfect companion for the Sibelius Symphony No. 7
that follows it and concludes the concert.
Sibelius completed his seventh and final symphony in 1924 after
considerable labor and revisions. This brief (around 22 minutes)
one-movement work is, as conductor Joshua
Weilerstein writes, “a piece that is barely a symphony at
all, and yet carries symphonic logic throughout.” Indeed, at its
premiere (with Sibelius conducting) it was billed as “Fantasia
Sinfonica” (“Symphonic Fantasy”) No. 1. It wasn’t until a year
later that the composer decided that it was, in fact, an actual
symphony—and one of which he was proud. “A great success,” he
wrote after the first performance. “There is no denying it: my new
work is one of the best. Tone and ‘colour’ both powerful.”
A lot of ink and pixels have been spilled in analyses of the
Sibelius Seventh over the past century, with much argument about
what its actual form might be, what it really means, and other
questions that are such great fodder for academic papers and blog
posts. Weilerstein’s “Sticky
Notes” episode on the work has the advantage of being clear
and filled with musical illustrations. I recommend it.
Issues of structure and other musical nuts and bolts aside,
though, the ultimate question for the listener is: what does it
sound like and how does it feel? To me it sounds and feels
mercurial, constantly shifting emotions, defying expectations, and
ultimately ambiguous. Now it’s lamenting, now it’s breaking into a
little folk dance, now it’s triumphant, and now it’s…over. And
it’s not all that clear what actually happened.
Sir Simon Rattle, who conducts the performance in the SLSO
playlist, says the Symphony No. 7 ends with an existential scream
while Weilerstein says “it is a cosmic ending, almost like the
launch of the note C into outer space.” I say it just…stops. And
leaves us to decide what happens after that. Grey skies and
whistling winds will probably figure into it somehow.
 |
Beethoven
in 1803
Painted by Christian Horneman |
That said, the concert won’t be all stormy weather. The first
half concludes with the Piano Concerto No. 2 in B-flat major, Op.
19, by Ludwig van Beethoven (1771–1827), a work with a sunny
outlook and strong echoes of Mozart, and especially in the finale,
Haydn. Written before but published after the Concerto No. 1, it
marks the beginning of Beethoven's dual careers as pianist and
composer of concerti for his instrument of choice.
Outside of that finale, Haydn is mostly hiding in this work,
though. It's ultimately all Beethoven. That's particularly obvious
in the dramatic cadenza, written around 14 years after the
concerto.
The last time the SLSO
performed the Second Concerto, the ebullient Nicholas
McGegan with conducted with South Korean (b. 1994) virtuoso
Seong-Jin Cho at the keyboard. This time the soloist will be the
remarkable Marie-Ange Nguci (b.
1998), whose biography is impressive, to say the least.
Clearly a prodigy, the Franco-Albanian pianist was only 13 when
she won her first competition, the 2011 Lagny-sur-Marne
International Piano Competition. That same year she was accepted
into Nicholas Angelich’s class at the Paris Conservatoire. Today,
she holds degrees in Musicology, Musical Analysis, and Music
Pedagogy (Paris Sorbonne, Paris Conservatoire), an MBA in Cultural
Management, and a performance diploma in ondes martenot
(essentially a Theremin with a keyboard; Messiaen famously used it
in his 1949 “Turangalîla-Symphonie”).
Oh, yeah: she’s also studying conducting at Vienna’s University
of Music and Performing Arts.
“En Miror” (“In the
mirror”), her 2017 debut album on the Mirare label, consists
of piano music by composers known for their skills as organists
and improvisers: César Franck, J.S. Bach, Camille Saint-Saëns, and
Thierry Escaich. And her busy concert
schedule includes appearances with the Orchestre Symphonique de
Montréal, Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra, Orchestra della
Svizzera Italiana, Minnesota Orchestra, Detroit Symphony
Orchestra, and Macao Symphony Orchestra. It’s impressive, one must
admit.
The Essentials: John Storgårds conducts the orchestra and
soloist Marie-Ange Nguci in Beethoven’s Piano Concerto No. 2. The
concert also includes the Symphony No. 7 and “Rakastava (The
Lover)” by Sibelius along with “Lysning (Glade)” by contemporary
Danish composer Per Nørgård. Performances take place Friday at 10:30 am, Saturday at 7:30 pm,
and Sunday at 3 pm, April 19 through 21, at the Touhill
Performing Arts Center on the University of Missouri-St. Louis
campus. The Saturday evening concert will be broadcast live on St.
Louis Public Radio and Classic 107.3.